Used Rolex Watches New YorkUsed Rolex Watches for Sale in New York, NYC

Welcome to TopNotch Watch, the premier destination for used Rolex watches in New York City. Whether you’re in Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, or Staten Island, our website offers a diverse collection of 100% authentic, pre-owned Rolex timepieces for you to explore. Find your perfect watch and enjoy a seamless buying experience with TopNotch Watch.

Browse Our Collection

Exclusive Selection of Used Rolex Watches in NYC

Our passion for luxury timepieces drives us to offer an exclusive selection of used Rolex watches. At TopNotch Watch, we pride ourselves on the meticulous selection and maintenance of our Rolex inventory, ensuring you receive a premium watch at a competitive price. With our extensive network and industry connections, we can help you find the perfect Rolex, even if it’s not currently in our catalog.

Family-Owned Passion for Excellence

The dedicated family duo behind TopNotch Watch, Scott and Lisa Levin, have transformed their love for high-quality Swiss watches into a thriving business. Their commitment to providing the best pre-owned Rolex watches at unbeatable prices has earned them a loyal customer base. With a focus on integrity, professionalism, and unmatched service, Scott and Lisa ensure every customer has an outstanding experience.

Unmatched Customer Support for New Yorkers

At TopNotch Watch, we understand the value of top-tier support. Our knowledgeable team is ready to guide you through purchasing and address any questions or concerns. If you can’t find the specific watch you’re looking for, our industry connections enable us to locate it quickly.

Contact Us

TopNotch Watch is proud to serve New York City, from the bustling streets of Manhattan to the vibrant neighborhoods of Brooklyn and beyond. We’ll securely ship your used Rolex to your doorstep, no matter where you are in NYC. If you prefer to pick up your watch in person, visit our showroom in Buffalo. Explore our website or call us at (716) 510-7600. We’re excited to help you find the perfect Rolex timepiece. Choose TopNotch Watch as your go-to destination for used Rolex watches in New York, NY.

Contact Us

Customer Testimonials

Here’s what our satisfied customers in New York have to say about their experience with TopNotch Watch:

I’m extremely pleased with my Rolex purchase. Scott and Lisa have one of the best selections anywhere, and if they don’t have what you’re looking for, they can always find it. Very personable and a wonderfully run family business. Service is tops and most importantly, both are trustworthy and honest. Once you deal with TopNotch Watch, I promise you’ll be a customer for life. Thanks, guys! - Jim L.
I would strongly recommend TopNotch Watch to anyone considering buying a fine timepiece. They are honest, reliable, and offer substantial discounts over other stores. I bought my new Rolex Submariner from Scott and got a great deal. I have referred them to friends who had great experiences like I did. My watch arrived two days after I bought it just as described - the beautiful Rolex in the box with all the paperwork. Buy with confidence! Don’t be foolish - it’s your money - buy from TopNotch Watch! - Patrick O.